Articulation: Prerequisite to Performance pt.2
We continue exploring a 1989 AES paper by Art Noxon, TubeTrap inventor and ASC founder and President, that explains the use of the Modulation Transfer Function to measure intelligibility of a sound reproduction system. This week we see the relationship between articulation of an audio system and the room’s signal-to-noise ratio, a concept familiar to many in the electronic world, but not as well-known in the acoustic realm.
Read the entire paper
Signal to Noise Ratio
By now it should be clear that an articulation test measures both the dynamic and static behavior of sound levels. A third-octave or other RTA device measures static sound level conditions. The sound levels of a facility can be measured first without and later with a signal applied and the MTF can be evaluated with respect to background noise.
The background noise spectrum can be loaded into “Memory A” of an RTA. Then power up the sound system and measure pink noise levels at the listening position. Load them into “Memory B.” The difference between these two curves is the SNR vs. frequency curve. An example of this is shown in Figure 3.
The SNR can be converted to MTF by using Figure 1. The resulting TI (Transmission Index) vs. frequency curve of Figure 4 is a linear, unweighted response curve. For speech intelligibility the TI is multiplied by the weighting curve for (Figure 1) speech.
The result shown in Figure 5 is the band-limited STF (Speech Transfer Function) curve. The percent of the area coverage under the STF equals the STI, Speech Transmission Index.
This signal to background noise version of MTF analysis is fairly straight forward. Most of us in audio could produce today the STI by using an RTA, the MTF-S/N chart, the STF weighting curve and a lot of data plotting. This version of MTF has limited application. Conceptually, it measures the quality of communication for an anechoic chamber filled with background noise, the announcer system in a noisy, large factory or the PA for a huge, noisy crowd of people might be a reasonable application.
Signal to RT-60 Ratio
The other aspect of MTF includes reverberation, the more common problem in audio playback. Reverberation is the energy that lingers after a signal has been transmitted. No matter how reverberant a space may be, the residual energy will eventually die away leaving the ambient background noise as the sound in the room. If an alarm went off every hour in a reverb chamber a valid signal would be received because the time between signals far exceeds the decay time of the reverb chamber. Conversely, a high-speed Morse code transmitting four bursts per second would be converted to a total blur of noise, completely inaudible signal modulation.
As a consequence of reverberation, the signal modulation rate or bursts per second is related to the MTF. Slow burst rates naturally have good MTF and fast burst rates often have poor MTF. The range of burst rates that matter to people and communication is the range from 2 Hz to 20 Hz and the MTF vs. Reverberation, shown in Figure 6. Burst rates above 20 Hz sound like a low frequency note and therefore are not capable of being a modulate signal.
Real World MTF
The two basic versions of signal-to-noise have been presented. Background noise and reverberation are combined in most real-life situations. If the MTF for these two independent processes can be determined and the combined effect is desired, then we multiply the background noise MTF by the RT-60 MTF. The result gives the combined effect of substantial background noise in a reverberant space.
For example, consider a noise basketball game in a gymnasium. The crowd noise level could be 85 dB,A. The PA might be set at 90 dB. The RT-60 of the occupied gym might be 2.5 seconds. Shown in Figure 7 the SNR of 5 dB gives 75% partial MTF due to the PA level and crowd noise. The MTF/RT-60 curve gives a partial MTF of about 50% due to the gym reverberance at 2 bursts/sec. The combined effect is a MTF of about 35%, pretty bad. Successful announcers instinctively understand this and enunciate slowly to utilize the intelligibility benefits that go with slow modulation rates.






